|
Author
|
Topic: This ones moral diversity - bear with me (no stones please)
|
=DNX= Matrix Member
|
posted May 18, 2002 01:16 PM
I was rather hoping dreamer would explain it to hut - i dont think my eng-ger translation capabilities are quite up to it - i can do "yes","no" and "1 to 10" tho !!IP: |
[AoD]Sheedo Member
|
posted May 18, 2002 04:14 PM
I think its a very good idea matrix, Of course me coming from 1.0 in bz, the very 1st version, I am well aware of what story you are telling, and I cannot wait to see what you have planned for the BZ Mod, I have seen Pics, as well as Most of the AoD members have also.It is good that you are doing this for our game bro, Bz once had 350 people on a single server, now it has maybe 90 IF its a Friday or Saturday, it's a very old game, but its a game WELL worth remembering, and anyone that has played Bz knows exactly what im talking about. so i think its a good idea bro, and I cant wait,You may very well bring more bzers to this game, with this bz mod. But I understand its going to be a while before the Mod comes out, and I am willing to wait like everyone else, Just dont forget my stealth or my bomber, and we are good to go  IP: |
[AoD]Sheedo Member
|
posted May 18, 2002 04:19 PM
bz 1.0 to BZ 2** IP: |
=DNX= Matrix Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 04:53 AM
Ok the german NAZI bz units are completed. (this is when i expect the stones).... anyway take a look b4 we go any further. IP: |
SuperUnknown Administrator
|
posted May 22, 2002 05:02 AM
They look good Matrix.But I thought they would be realistic WWII tanks not when they strike again in 2062  IP: |
coaxs Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 05:07 AM
Realism is one thing, that is quite an other. I doubt there will be any acceptance of that.------------------ Tread Marks Ladders IP: |
Dudymas Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 06:13 AM
so you're trying to take realism and force it through the tiny hole we call Tread Marks.... It can work, but not without shaving a ton off the mod or enlarging the hole.... and the hole seems a little harder to enlarge. Woooo, I spoke in metaphors! I don't disagree with this mod, but I sure as anything don't think it'll be any fun if you use too much realism.[This message has been edited by Dudymas (edited May 22, 2002).] IP: |
=DNX= Matrix Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 07:18 AM
I did originally state they would be for the bz mod unless people missed that. If realism is a bad thing why would WW2 versions be acceptable and future ones not ? and for that matter why does it matter what period of time im trying to create.War is hell - it happened, it cant be shut out or simply dismissed. Besides this whole shebang is based on war right ? so wheres the issue ? its all ok having good guys to fight each other but when a diverse bad guy comes in (and they are always needed in war lets face it, whats war without factions) nobody will accept it. I went ahead on the strength that ppl said "sure np" instead if actually reading what I initially wrote and understanding it. So despite what ppl said, it seems the swastica still is deemed an offensive symbol. If i were to change the symbol i suspect there would not be an issue - its an interesting thing isnt it...... what ppl say is acceptable and what is not. Its ok for existing tanks not future ones, yet the tank shape is not the issue, the symbol is - interesting...... yes very interesting.... [This message has been edited by =DNX= Matrix (edited May 22, 2002).] IP: |
Karldar Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 12:51 PM
I think it's interesting that the iron cross is less offensive to most people than the swastika even though the NAZI's used both. Prolly be more acceptable to replace the swastikas with pentagrams or inverted crosses, Rixy...lol.------------------ I like pie, but I LOVE TM! IP: |
MexIndian Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 01:01 PM
stop matrix, you got it twisted bro. We all knew the tanks were for the BZ mod, but we didn't VISUALIZE new tanks (I know I'm not familiar with BZ so couldn't envision it). We figured you'd re-create old tanks and insert them into the BZ mod. It was a simple misunderstanding, that's all.The tank meshes kick a$$ tho. ------------------ If I were you and you were me and I fragged you whose score would go up? IP: |
Grind_and_Click Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 01:22 PM
well you did say they would be more clunky clok work, but they arent........no biggy!??!the meshes look damn fine, i think you should keep them the way they are i think they look excelent, if they didnt have a nazi symbol then i think it would take the history out of them, history is a story teller, if it was some made up faction that did everything that the nazis did in the story line like in SÒF it ruins it cos you can tell they are trying to avoid confrontation, thats just weak especialy when u know it. i hope it stays the way they are, just wont have atmos without the reality [This message has been edited by Grind_and_Click (edited May 22, 2002).] IP: |
-DNX-Ni Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 01:35 PM
Coax has a point there! They are looking fine, mesh-wise man you ca't say anything much less about it.But won't you be tired eventually of people taking offense to it, judging you and you have to explain that you actually asked a community to see if it might be accepted as part of a modding batch. Sorry to 8itch on about it. A change in symbol might be a plausible alternative, but adhering to the colours of the tank doesn't take away ro the fact that 'random joe' will dissect it and the modder too. Although it was accepted in SOF after all. ------------------ The Ahn-NI-hilator IP: |
Grind_and_Click Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 02:04 PM
AND day of defeat AND wolfenstein and any other game involving naziism films, books, GAMES WHO GIVES A POO?!, its just adding a known tyranical force instead of a made up enemy that has NO history, its good but not as good as making it somthing you can relate to as being bad and fearsome sorry i just think its beter that way =/ [This message has been edited by Grind_and_Click (edited May 22, 2002).] IP: |
Karldar Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 02:10 PM
[run-on sentence]Actually, it sounded to me like /2ixy was saying that the guy he was talking to recommended the skins and clunky WWII tanks, but the BZ mod was only gonna use the skins with swastikas and Matrix was concerned about the reception of said skins.[/run-on sentence]IP: |
coaxs Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 03:10 PM
I guess I just don't see why you would have to include it. No biggie to me though. IP: |
-DNX-Ni Member
|
posted May 22, 2002 03:33 PM
Well ok...DOD an all then it wouldn't be neo-naziism would it? They're the old, Hitler times. Unless the Neo part of the batch there is to do with it being in the future, but if people were referring to the older tanks then it's not really of the neo sorts!Oh, so what anyway?? I'm just saying people are gonna give Matrix a hard time I reckon so some kind of statement might b required as a sort of disclaimer to the hwole thing! I personally don't care..if there's a plot and if the tanks are integral to it. fari enough! ------------------ The Ahn-NI-hilator IP: |
SuperUnknown Administrator
|
posted May 22, 2002 03:48 PM
I have no problem with it,but you could make is a devil worshipping star or the Russian Sickel and Hammer if you want to avoid problems.Wasn't BZ a fight between Ferderation and Russians...I can really remember because its been a while.The tanks do look cool and I have no problem with them.IP: |
=DNX= Matrix Member
|
posted May 23, 2002 12:18 AM
The original bz was american vs russian (cca vs nsdf) - bz red odyssey assded the chineese to the onslaught and german & british units have been created since - my point is simpoly that we all have logos, all sides did attrocities, granted nobody likes nazi'ism but it happened. It was war - and it has as much need of representation as any other side.The fact that many ppl consider it a strong moral issue if used in games certainly shows that their influence of fear still lives on today as a topic ppl are unwilling to cover. I think the best bet would be to make a sepoerate (by your own morals) download thus leaving the choice of inclusion down to the player. Its like top shelf skin mags - theyre on display, not everyone agrees with em, nobody is forced to buy em, but ppl do anyway. Looking backacross films n stuff the symbol in "V" was almost exactly like the swastica and in a future vein, also is star wars not running in close parallels ? IP: |
Grind_and_Click Member
|
posted May 23, 2002 01:11 AM
so are you gona make both the downloads the same butt different (if you do it) , by that what i mean is, all the files will be named the same but from how the person playing views it it will be as they wana see it?like i pik the nazi skins , some other dude spiks different skins, i see nazi tanks he sees alternate tanks cos the fils were both named the same? if you do it  IP: |
Bonzo Dog Member
|
posted May 25, 2002 04:19 AM
Before the Germans got hold of it the swastica used to run clockwise and was a good luck symbol, just a thought.IP: |
HUT Member
|
posted May 25, 2002 04:43 AM
[This message has been edited by HUT (edited June 12, 2002).] IP: |
reddog Member
|
posted May 25, 2002 07:25 AM
I think anything goes myself, this is a War "Game" lets fight it out in our tanks off choice. It's only a game chaps. Get in ya tanks men.IP: |
=DNX= Matrix Member
|
posted May 25, 2002 07:46 AM
Alternate skins is a very interesting way of tackling the situation and certainly the way ill do it - ill rename the faction using an acronym and make a "safe" skin for general download with an optional "nazi" skin for those who prefer such.btw - HUT, my uncle oliver was a paratrooper and shot during a mission to arnham, so i know how u feel. Maybe i make em so tharmour of 1 so they can get the $hite pummelled out of em lol ! - interesting revenge when u control their tanks for a change lol  IP: |
=DNX= Matrix Member
|
posted May 25, 2002 10:46 AM
Oki dokie time to get a few things sorted out here.1) Im not guido or corpse lol 2) im not racist, even tho ive just been accused of such via email. 3) im making the skin downloadable as an option, much like a top shelf mag nobody is forcing you to use it, and if you do so - it will only be seen on your own computer as the filenames will be the same. 4) im a non-voting anti political neutral unactivist with no religeion  5) you dont see viets attacking the game cos theres a usa flag on it - nor do you see anyone poking at the jewish flag in the flag pack - religeon here is not an issue its a neutral. 6) cant escape the past - or indeed the future. 7) theres alreadya multitude of games as dreamer noted like wolfenstein, and a million others you could mention - big seller by the way - and as this link shows theres lots of skins for that too. ( http://www.wolfensteincenter.com/downloads/skins.phtml ) 8) im not trying to justify the nazi's - im just giving them a game based representation so we can ahmmer the smeg outa em lol. 9) im not forcing it down your throats - im making the skins an optional download - so it up to the user what they see, and what they find acceptable. Oki onto the email comments with my -ed:
i work with a jewish person and hes a GOOD FRIEND (my next door neighbour is one and hes been helping me with the skins !! -ed)
there was no county adenafid in TM when it came out and it should STAY that way. (i have no plans to make such a map -ed) whats next Talibon tanks? (if you want them i suppose.... im happy to put any logo on any tank if theres call for it - my mod just happens to call for it - its a touchy subject, but its not going away no matter how much we avoid it -ed) i know way don't you have babys running around so we can run them over too . (thats a sick mind man, i made one with teletubbies tho if you want to try that -ed) if you going to bring in the NAZI , you mite as well go ALL the way . (not needed for my mod, but thx for the thought -ed) i live in the usa (ok... so what ? -ed) im white (and this means sumthin to me ? -ed) i play as IDGAF= i dont give a fuk (apparently u do!-ed) im 35 (ahh nice, im 31 -ed) if i want to play a nazi game i'll put in return to castle wolfenstein (big seller tha good game -ed) all i was asking is how far is it going to go, you start with the nazis . y the nazis? (why not ? if you can pick another evil faction will ppl who hate them not be offended ? - -ed) this game came out with no boarders , so lets keep it that way. (yes it did, i however am remaking a game that does have borders -and its a mod, so like a top shelf magazine, if you dont like it - dont download it ! -ed) - ed (At the end of the days it will be down to your own morals weather you download the skins or not - ive had many emails stating how nice they are .... or shall we dress up in teletubbie outfits, throw daisies at each other and throw projectiles that comment on how "splendidly shiny our tank is today" when they almost hit, but then turn into a puff of pink smoke and settle gently to the ground.  Im making a horror one too - i assume youre not against me thumping a few zombies ? hhehe chill out - its a game, not even that its a mod..... and you have the choice of what you download unlike wolfenstein that simply unpacks it onto your hard drive. Ive taken every precaution not to offend which was the point of this thread. And i can do without such abusive emails too - put your concerns in plain english sensibly and you will get a sensible answer... 72 point fonts in italic colours dont impress me lol. [This message has been edited by =DNX= Matrix (edited May 25, 2002).] IP: |
MexIndian Member
|
posted May 28, 2002 02:09 PM
It'll be interesting to see who decides to use the Nazi tanks as theirs.------------------ If I were you and you were me and I fragged you whose score would go up? IP: | |